Pumpkin Gill?

  • bigstorm
    Southern WI
    Posts: 1348
    #1673507

    Out fishing with my wife yesterday and she caught a very strange colored pumpkinseed. Looking at the picture, the bottom one has a much different color pattern and in sunlight, it is a light blue in color. Someone mentioned it is a pumpkin gill. Anyone caught one of these before?

    Attachments:
    1. Pumpkin-Gill.jpeg

    MNSmallieGuy
    Minnesota
    Posts: 109
    #1673581

    I have been told the red ear makes them pumpkin seeds but without, they are what are known as hybrids. Maybe someone else can confirm.

    outdoors4life
    Stillwater, MN
    Posts: 1500
    #1673583

    They both look like pure Pumpkins to me. Most of the time there is variation to the colors and markings. The red on the ear flaps look pretty small but normal.

    Brady Valberg
    Posts: 326
    #1673584

    Maybe somethin similar to a blue perch???

    Attachments:
    1. 20170211_105016.jpg

    nick_harrison
    Garrison, IA
    Posts: 146
    #1673604

    If they have the red on their ear, here they would be a red eared sunfish. Called a red ear for short.

    Attachments:
    1. Screenshot_20170213-101441.png

    WinnebagoViking
    Inactive
    Posts: 420
    #1673609

    If they have the red on their ear, here they would be a red eared sunfish. Called a red ear for short.

    Two different fish; Pumpkinseed is Lepomis gibbosus and Red Ear is Lepomis microlophus

    nick_harrison
    Garrison, IA
    Posts: 146
    #1673613

    Can pumpkinseeds still have red on their ear? I always assumed the red on their ear made them a red ear. I didn’t look at the picture real close to see if they had the red on them. I was going off of the first reply that said he thought the red ear made them a pumpkinseed.

    tegg
    Hudson, Wi/Aitkin Co
    Posts: 1450
    #1673649

    Can pumpkinseeds still have red on their ear? I always assumed the red on their ear made them a red ear. I didn’t look at the picture real close to see if they had the red on them. I was going off of the first reply that said he thought the red ear made them a pumpkinseed.

    Correct. Pumpkinseeds have a red spot on the end of the ear.

    I was also wondering if this was a hybrid. Darker colored fish but has some coloration consistent with a pumpkinseed but also has a black ear consistent with a bluegill. The lake it came from has both sunfish.

    Attachments:
    1. sunfish.jpg

    Ny
    N Metro
    Posts: 172
    #1673652

    I believe that its a Hybrid

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.