I have the simms challenger suit both insulated and uninsulated and love them both. Not much I would change on them besides the price.. I own a lot of Simms gear and have never been disappointed with them. That being said, blackfish is right up there with Simms in quality and maybe a little cheaper. I don’t think you can go wrong with either brands, get whatever you like/ is in budget.
Simms does make some quality Gear. Just way out of my Budget. Had I not got a really good discount on my blackfish Rain gear, I’m not sure I would have even got it.
I spend a fair amount of time in the boat each summer, and most my raingear in the past have tended to last a rather long time. This is the only reason I can seem to justify the $ I spent on the blackfish raingear I purchased.