Interesting responses – and pretty much what I was expecting.
Jon – you mentioned that many fish reach max weight before they reach max age. Interesting that you should say this. A few years back, I iced a 9.5lb lake trout that was tagged. I clobbered it for the smoker – not thinking much of it. I sent the tag info to the ministry to get the fish’s bio. I was informed that it was a male that was tagged 3 years prior about 2 miles from where I caught it(no surprises there). The surprising info was that the fish’s tagging data showed it to be 1/2 ” longer when it was tagged and .5 lbs heavier. I attribute this to the inconsistencies in my measurement vs the netters measurements of a squirming fish. The weights, I believe were pretty accurate, as my scale is the same as the ministry creel clerks scale – and was calibrated by them on the ice. So in 3 years, the trout did not grow any in length – and actually lost 1/2 lb!! Oh yeah – the trout was 18 yrs old when tagged – making it 21yrs old when I caught it. I would say that the male trout I caught was either at or very near max size. Just like people, each individual fish only can get so big.
Tim